Byrds Album Ratings

 

Thirty Byrds Albums Rated From Up To Sixteen Sources, Compiled By David Chirko, Sudbury ON (see:

www.eol.ca/acsa/chirko.html, www.canartscene.com/members/dchirko, www.theontariopoetrysociety.ca, www.federationofpoets.com/featuredavidchirko.htm)

  

 

Album  Average Score  Sources  &  Individual Ratings (# out of 5 points)

 

Byrds Box--4.8

AMG-5, MHR-5, RRG-5, RSA-5, VIE-5;

 

Mr. Tambourine Man—4.75

AAR-4.75, AMA-5, AMG-5, JFR-4, MHR-5, MRR-4.5, RRG-5, RSA-5, RSR-5, VAT-5, VIE-4;

 

Notorious Byrd Brothers—4.667

AAR-5, AMA-5, AMG-5, MHR-4, MRR-4, RRG-5, RSA-4, RSR-4, RST2-5, VAT-5, VFM-5, VIE-5;

 

Turn! Turn! Turn!--4.625

AAR-4.25, AMA-4.5, AMG-5, JFR-3.5, MHR-5*, MRR-5, RSA-5, RSR-5, VAT-5, VIE-4;

 

Younger Than Yesterday—4.596

AAR-4.25, AMA-5, AMG-5, JFR-4, MHR-4, MRR-4.5, RRG-5, RSA-4, RSR-4, RST2-5, VAT-5, VFM-5, VIE-5;

 

Greatest Hits—4.583

AMA-4.5, AMG-5, MHR-4, RSA-5, RSR-5, VIE-4;

 

Very Best Of (1997)—4.5

AMA-5, VIE-4;

 

Sweetheart Of The Rodeo—4.438

AAR-3.75, AMA-4.5, AMG-5, JFR-4, MHR-5, MRR-2.5, RSA-4.5, RSR-5, RST-5, VAT-5, VFM-5, VIE-4;

 

Original Singles Volume I—4.4

AMA-5, AMG-5, MHR-3, RSA-5, VIE-4;

 

Fifth Dimension—4.318

AAR-4, AMA-5, AMG-5, JFR-4.5, MHR-3, MRR-4.5, RSA-3.5, RSR-4, SH-5, VAT-5, VIE-4;

 

Definitive Collection—4

AMA-4;

 

Ballad Of Easy Rider—3.813

AAR-3.5, AMA-4.5, AMG-4, MHR-3, MRR-3, RSA-4.5, RSR-5**, VIE-3;

 

Untitled—3.806

AAR-4.25, AMA-4.5, AMG-4, HIE-5, MHR-4, MRR-1.5, RSA-4, RSR-3, VIE-4;

 

Twenty Essential Tracks—3.8

AMA-4, AMG-3, MHR-4, RSA-4, VIE-4;

 

 

Dr. Byrds and Mr. Hyde—3.5

AAR-4.5, AMA-4.5, AMG-3, MHR-3, MRR-4, RSA-3, RSR-3, VIE-3;

 

Original Singles Volume II—3.5

AMG-4, VIE-3;

 

3 Byrds Land In London—3.5

AMA-3.5;

 

Very Best Of (1986)—3.5

MHR-3, RSA-4;

 

Never Before—3.4

AMG-3, MHR-4, MRR-4, RSA-3, VIE-3;

 

In The Beginning—3.333

AMA-4, AMG-3, RSA-3, VIE-3;

 

Live At The Fillmore 1969—3.313

AAR-3.25, AMA-4, AMG-3, MRR-3;

 

Preflyte—3.214

AAR-3.5, AMG-3, MHR-3, MRR-3.5, RSA-3.5, RSR-4, VIE-2;

 

Greatest Hits Volume II—3

AMA-3, AMG-2, MHR-3, RSA-5, RSR-2, VIE-3;

 

Byrds Play Dylan—3

AMG-2, MHR-3, RSA-4;

 

History Of—3

AMG-2, VIE-4;

 

Byrds Collection—3

VIE-3;

 

Farther Along—2.571

AAR-3.5, AMA-4, AMG-3, MHR-2, MRR-2.5, RSA-3, VIE-0;

 

Byrdmaniax—2.393

AAR-3.25, AMA-3, AMG-2, MHR-2, MRR-1.5, RSA-3, VIE-2;

 

Byrds—2.083

AMA-2, AMG-2, MHR-1, MRR-2.5, RSA-2, VIE-3;

 

Doin’ All Right—0.5

AMG-1, VIE-0;

 

 

*in another edition; **”masterpiece”

 

Average score of all albums: 3.597/5 points

 

Legend:

 

AAR Adrian’s Album Reviews (January 2002)

AMA Amazon.com (October, 2000)

AMG All Music Guide (2001)

HIE The Harmony Illustrated Encyclopedia of Rock (1988) [album 5/5 if “Worth Searching Out”]

JFR Jack Feeny Reviews (2006)

MHR Music Hound Rock The Essential Album Guide (1996)

MRR Mark Prindle’s Record Review Guide

RRG Rock the Rough Guide (1996) [album 5/5 if included]

RSA Rolling Stone Album Guide (1992)

RSR Rolling Stone Record Guide (1979)

RST Rolling Stone (magazine) Top 100 Albums Of The Last 20 Years (1987) [album 5/5 if included]

RST2 Rolling Stone (magazine) Top 100 Albums (1997) [album 5/5 if included)

SH Sunday Herald (September 2002) “the best (105) albums ever…honest” by

 David Keenan (album 5/5 if included)

VAT Virgin All Time Top 1000 Albums (1998) [album 5/5 if included]

VFM Vanity Fair (magazine) (November 2000) “The Best Of The Best (Elvis) Costello’s 500” [5/5]

VIE Virgin Illustrated Encyclopedia Of Rock (1998)

 

 

Return to Jonathan and David's Byrds Page